They say the mystery and eccentricity of
folktales is something that always remains with you. As a child I don’t remember
questioning Bikram and Baital or any of their 25 tales. But today, I do find
myself wondering what the fuss about
the 110 minutes of Qissa is.
Set against the backdrop of Punjab, Qissa
is the story of a father and his child. Umber Singh (Irrfan Khan) obsessed with
his desire for a male child, decides to bring his fourth daughter (Shome) up as
a boy. Along the way he’s successful in depriving the mother (Chopra) of a
voice and a conscience, and through the years, he manages to cheat the other
sisters and the entire village about
Kanwar’s chromosomes.
As Qissa progresses we get pulled into the
dark twisted undercurrent of a fathers sick persistence of believing the
daughter to be a son and in turn, her mental struggle to live up to the fathers
expectations by defying all odds to play being something she’s not.
To be honest, it is but a story, unreal,
and that which defies logic or mathematics. Given that, I sat through, wanting
to know how the delusional father dealt with Kanwars puberty, no facial hair,
questions about peeing in the open, breasts, or falling for a girl. At some
point I was expecting Kanwar to break down burdened by her true identity, but
what further perplexed me was a marriage, the fathers incestuous behavior to
ensure a male legacy and an indistinct conclusion to the Qissa.
Unfortunately, what emerged was the feeling
of listening to a bored child, weaving a story as he went along. A lot many said this was not a film to think
about rationally, the story was as captivating as was the acting, and that one would
just be riveted in the tale.
Is that the criteria then for mass hysteria
and global awards?
Despite
loosing it’s path in parts, and the screenplay dragging a bit, have to give it
to Anup Singh and Madhuja Mukherjee for being brave to experiment. Brilliant
performance by Dugal. Shome came around towards the end, Khan and Chopra had no
challenge.
Through the
film I was disturbed about how a story of female oppression completely left a
mother’s point of view out, the character was so inconsistent and conveniently
disappeared from the screenplay at all times when her presence would have
created a fork in the story.
Is this
what got the foreign markets to sit up and take note? There is a lot more to
story telling and to India.
The end did
leave me haunted, wondering a little and confused some more. I do not however,
take that as the objective of the film and yet success.